État :
4.84.8 étoiles sur 5
11 évaluations du produit
  • 5étoiles

    9évaluations
  • 4étoiles

    2évaluations
  • 3étoiles

    0évaluation
  • 2étoiles

    0évaluation
  • 1étoile

    0évaluation

Would recommend100% J'accepte

Good value100% J'accepte

Good quality100% J'accepte

9 avis

par

Gil Evans has done a tremendous job.

I have bought this CD when I had only heard one track from the record- Boplicity. I have fallen in love with Gil Evans' music and that is why I immediately decided to buy the record. PLus I have read Miles Davis' autobiography, where he talked about the album in really superlative terms.
Now about the CD. Gil Evans did a tremendous job with arranging the 2 songs he arranged, Boplicity and Moon Dreams. I personally was not too astonished by Gerry Mulligan's arrangements, I cannot seem to find my way into Mulligan's playing and arranging.
That is the actual reason, why I rated this album "only" good, not excelent, because I have bought it to hear Gil Evans' arrangements, and there were only two of them (which I was not aware of when I was purchasing the CD), and the rest were Mulligan's or Lewis' arrangements, and those did not thrill me that much. Still the CD is very good, I like the idea that Miles Davis thought of- the idea of 6 horns playing as a choir, with the rhythm section behind them. It sound very natural, peaceful and beautiful. Lee Konitz, Miles Davis and Gerry Mulligan did a good job soloing, my favorite being Lee Konitz.
My personal favorite on the whole album is Boplicity, being a superb composition and beautifully arranged piece.
I still recommend to buy the album, because it brings a different view in playing jazz and Miles Davis' fans (and Gil Evans' fans) should cerainly buy this CD. But do not expect that arrangements of Mulligan and Lewis will be equally interesting and thrilling as the arrangements of Gil Evans.
Lire l'avis complet...

par

Rating a classic recording is easy

It's not just me - this album is a classic in jazz. Rolling Stone rates it as 5 stars, as does AllMusic. Some of the tunes on here have become jazz classics. Originally released as 78 rpm singles, you can imagine the digital improvement in the current release over the original releases. It's really a piece of thoroughly enjoyable jazz history.Lire l'avis complet...

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : *gopeachy*

par

Great album

I've been a Miles Davis fan for years. This album is one of his milestones in his career. If you're a jazz fan you should appreciate this album.

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : decluttr_store

par

Superb

Your record Ed quality is outstanding! I felt rewarded to find your company on line. I will be making a return order 👌

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : second.sale

par

great CD

very cool cat

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : decluttr_store

par

Good pre-Quintet Miles

Pre-Quintet Miles from late 40s & early 50s...

Very good music indeed

par

Birth of the Cool

Short at 36 minutes, but we'll worth it in musical terms.

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : decluttr_store

par

Amazing!

I don't know if amazing is enough to describe this collection of great tunes played by one of the best trumpet players ever. I recommend it to people from any age who appreciates the art of music--the art of Jazz. Cool jazz is great!!!Lire l'avis complet...

par

Great

Fantastic

Achat vérifié :  Oui | État : occasion | Vendu par : second.sale

Pourquoi cet avis est-il inapproprié?